Paul Williams

Paul Williams

Carlton Fields

Contact  |  View Bio  |  RSS

Latest Publications


Third Circuit Applies Presumption of Timeliness to Pre-Certification Motion to Intervene as Class Representative

This case concerned a federal antitrust class action involving a proposed class of Class 8 truck purchasers who alleged a conspiracy by several truck transmission suppliers and manufacturers to raise prices by eliminating...more

10/4/2016 - Anti-Competitive Antitrust Litigation Antitrust Violations Article III Auto Parts Automotive Industry Class Action Class Certification Class Representatives Direct Purchasers Manufacturers Price-Fixing Putative Class Actions Standing

Eighth Circuit Privacy Class Action Fails to Clear Second Hurdle

In Carlsen v. GameStop Inc., plaintiff ­– a paid subscriber to defendant’s online gaming magazine – brought a putative class action lawsuit against defendant for alleged breach of its privacy policy by disclosing plaintiff’s...more

9/2/2016 - Article III Breach of Contract Class Action Consumer Fraud Data Breach Facebook Federal Rule 12(b)(1) GameStop Gaming Information Sharing Motion to Dismiss Online Gaming Personally Identifiable Information Popular Privacy Concerns Privacy Policy Standing Subject Matter Jurisdiction Unjust Enrichment Video Games

New Wave of COI Rate Increase Lawsuits Hits the Industry

Historically, increases to cost of insurance (COI) rates on universal life (UL) policies have been met with legal challenges from policyholders, and sometimes, regulatory opposition spurred by policyholder complaints. The...more

8/23/2016 - AXA Equitable Life Captive Insurance Company COI Rates Contract Terms Insurance Industry Insurance Litigation Life Insurance Reinsurance

Another One Bites the Dust: Maryland Federal District Court Dismisses Putative Data Breach Class Action for Lack of Standing

The United States District Court of Maryland recently dismissed a putative class action alleging that CareFirst’s failure to adequately secure the computer hardware storing their customers’ personal information led to two...more

6/30/2016 - Article III CareFirst Class Action Cyber Attacks Cybersecurity Data Breach Dismissals Hackers Health Insurance Identity Theft Insurance Industry Personally Identifiable Information Putative Class Actions Standing

Will Tender of Full Amount of Named Plaintiff’s Claim Moot a TCPA Class Action?

In Campbell-Ewald Co. v Gomez, 136 S.Ct. 663 (2016), the Supreme Court held that Rule 68 offers of judgment to a class representative do not moot a class action. The Supreme Court left open the possibility that an actual...more

3/28/2016 - Mootness Putative Class Actions Rule 68 TCPA Tender Offers

Biting The Hand That Fed Them – And Winning

Choice of law is frequently a prominent – and sometimes a pivotal – factor in a court’s analysis of whether to grant or deny certification of a nationwide or multi-state class. Whether a federal court may apply one...more

2/15/2016 - Class Action Class Certification Predominance Requirement Rule 23(b)(3)

Limits of Ascertainability Reached in Class Allegations Against Equifax

Plaintiff, hoping to recover from Equifax for issuing a credit report with “incorrect and damaging information,” sought to represent a class of “all persons who disputed an Equifax credit report and where Equifax failed to...more

2/3/2016 - Ascertainable Class Class Action Credit Reporting Agencies Credit Reports Equifax FCRA

No Automatic Certification For Robosigning Class

In this multidistrict litigation, plaintiffs sought certification of two classes of Arizona property owners challenging the operation of the Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems (MERS) in transferring the beneficial...more

1/13/2016 - Class Certification Deed of Trust MERS Mortgages Registration Transfer of Interest

eCommerce Regulation, Bitcoin, Anti-Money Laundering, Shadow Insurance, 401(k) Litigation [Expect Focus – Vol. IV, Fall 2015]

IN THE SPOTLIGHT - - California Passes Life and Annuity Electronic Transactions Law LIFE INSURANCE - - Under a Spotlight, "Shadow Insurance" Lawsuit Fails Scrutiny - NAIC Evaluates Insurer’s Use of Variable...more

1/11/2016 - 401k Administrative Proceedings Big Data Bitcoin BSA/AML E-Commerce Medical Devices SEC STOLI Takedown Notices Variable Annuities

Under a Spotlight, "Shadow Insurance" Lawsuit Fails Scrutiny

One of several class actions that arose in the wake of a 2013 investigation by the New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) into so-called “shadow insurance,” Robainas v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co., has been...more

1/4/2016 - Insurance Industry Life Insurance Misrepresentation NYDFS Premiums Reinsurance Standing

Arbitration Awards Prove an Obstacle to Class Claims

Two recent decisions illustrate the impact arbitration provisions can have on the availability of classwide relief. In Kaspers v. Comcast Corp., plaintiff, a Comcast customer, refused to pay for certain billed services...more

12/11/2015 - American Arbitration Association Arbitration Awards Class Action Class Action Arbitration Waivers

How to Handle Claims Brought by a Class Representative Under Laws of a Different State: Lessons from the Northern District of...

Arroyo v. TP-Link USA Corporation (N.D. Cal.) presents a varied opinion on the viability of class claims under California law, particularly as brought by a non-California class representative. Plaintiff, a Florida resident,...more

10/13/2015 - Breach of Warranty Class Action Class Representatives Consumers Legal Remedies Act Express Warranty False Advertising Motion to Dismiss Putative Class Actions Unfair Competition

Eleventh Circuit Doubles Down on “No Class Tolling” Rule

The Eleventh Circuit has doubled down on its prior holding that a pending class action will not toll the statute of limitations for a later class action seeking to represent the same class. Plaintiff brought a class action...more

8/13/2015 - Class Action Statute of Limitations TCPA Tolling

Nevada Federal District Court Follows National Trend, Dismisses Data Breach Class Action for Lack of Standing

In granting a motion to dismiss a data breach putative class action lawsuit, the District of Nevada joined the majority of federal district courts in holding that plaintiffs whose personal information was stolen lack Article...more

6/17/2015 - Article III Class Action Cyber Attacks Cybersecurity Data Breach Data Protection Hackers Motion to Dismiss Personally Identifiable Information Putative Class Actions Standing Starbucks Zappos

A Tale of Two Annuities: Exchange of Variable for Fixed Annuity Integral in SLUSA Dismissal

After attending an annuity seminar, Robert and Diane Ruud exchanged their variable annuity for a fixed annuity sold by PHL Variable. According to the Ruuds, seminar provider John Friendshuh represented the fixed annuity as...more

6/17/2015 - Annuities Broker Commissions Class Action Consumer Fraud Insurance Industry Life Insurance PHL Variable Insurance Company Putative Class Actions Securities SLUSA Unfair or Deceptive Trade Practices

Class Action Plaintiffs’ Failure to Appear at Deposition Deemed Not Prejudicial Enough for Dismissal

In a class action brought against Amtrak, two plaintiffs, Guerra and Whitesides, both of whom had submitted declarations in support of plaintiffs’ motion for class certification, failed to appear at their scheduled...more

5/21/2015 - Amtrak Class Action Depositions Dismissal With Prejudice Railways Willful Misconduct

Regulatory Settlement Proves Major Obstacle for Certification of Minor Class of Google In-App Purchases

Google sells apps on its Play Store that allow users to make in-app purchases, typically the buying of “currency” for use in app-based games. This putative class action alleged that the games were aimed at minor children and...more

4/23/2015 - FTC Google Play Minors Mobile Apps Putative Class Actions Virtual Currency

Circuit Courts Address Impact of Arbitration Agreements on Labor Class and Collective Actions

In Conners v. Gusano’s Chicago Style Pizzeria, plaintiffs, former employees of defendant, brought a collective action alleging violations of the Fair Labor Standards Act. Defendant responded by implementing a binding...more

3/27/2015 - Arbitration Arbitration Agreements Class Action Class Action Arbitration Waivers Collective Actions FLSA

Second Circuit Affirms Certification of Consumer Debt Collection Class, Distinguishing Comcast v. Behrend

These cases, on a consolidated appeal, involved three defendants: a company that purchased consumer debts, a debt collection law firm, and a process server. Plaintiffs had each been sued in various debt collection actions by...more

2/27/2015 - Case Consolidation Class Action Class Certification Comcast v. Behrend Consumer Fraud Debt Buyers Debt Collection Default Judgment FDCPA Fraud RICO

Insurance Balance Billing Class Fails Rule 23’s Requirements

Plaintiff filed a putative class action in Arkansas state court against his automobile insurer for alleged failure to pay the full amount it was contractually required to pay for his medical bills following a car accident. ...more

1/30/2015 - Auto Insurance CAFA Car Accident Class Action Insurance Industry Insurance Litigation Putative Class Actions Rule 23

Ninth and Tenth Circuits Address Removal Under CAFA's "Mass Action" and "State Action" Provisions

In Corber v. Xanodyne Pharmaceuticals, the Ninth Circuit – on rehearing en banc –examined the applicability of the “mass action” provision of CAFA, which provides federal jurisdiction for any civil action in which monetary...more

12/5/2014 - CAFA Class Action Employer Group Health Plans En Banc Review Federal Jurisdiction Health Insurance Pharmaceutical Industry Prescription Drugs Removal

Court Grants Motion to Strike Class Allegations

In granting a recent motion to strike class allegations, the Northern District of Illinois made two notable observations about such motions: first, they are not disfavored, but rather an appropriate device for determining...more

10/29/2014 - Class Action Employer Liability Issues FLSA Motion To Strike Putative Class Actions Wage and Hour

District Court Certifies Class Challenging ERISA Plan Amendment

The Eastern District of Michigan has certified a class of ERISA plan participants challenging an amendment which, in attempt to address the plan’s underfunded status, reduced their monthly disability payments. The Court...more

10/2/2014 - Class Action Class Certification Disability Disability Benefits ERISA Retirement

34 Results
View per page
Page: of 2

"My best business intelligence, in one easy email…"

Your first step to building a free, personalized, morning email brief covering pertinent authors and topics on JD Supra:

Sign up to create your digest using LinkedIn*

*By using the service, you signify your acceptance of JD Supra's Privacy Policy.

Already signed up? Log in here

*With LinkedIn, you don't need to create a separate login to manage your free JD Supra account, and we can make suggestions based on your needs and interests. We will not post anything on LinkedIn in your name. Or, sign up using your email address.