Stanley Gibson

Stanley Gibson

Jeffer Mangels Butler & Mitchell LLP

Contact  |  View Bio  |  RSS

Latest Publications


After Defendant Seeks to Claw Back Attorney-Client Privileged Documents, District Court Determines Privileged Waived (Including...

The defendants produced documents in response to plaintiffs' first set of requests for production and included in the production were five documents that the defendants were later claim were subject to attorney-client...more

7/28/2016 - Attorney-Client Privilege Clawbacks Depositions Discovery Federal Rules of Evidence Patent Litigation Privilege Waivers Rule 502 Work Product Privilege

District Court Orders Production of Bills from Expert Witnesses But Permits Redaction of Narrative Statements in Bills

In this patent infringement action, the defendant, Ericsson moved to compel the plaintiff, TCL, to produce bills and invoices for worked performed by TCL's expert witnesses. TCL sought to redact the bills and invoices to...more

7/26/2016 - Discovery Document Productions Ericsson Expert Witness Motion to Compel Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Redaction Rule 26

Subsequent Employment Agreement Assigning Inventor's Intellectual Property Rights Does not Defeat Standing for Inventions Created...

The plaintiff, Odyssey Wireless ("Odyssey") filed four separate actions for patent infringement against Defendants Apple, Samsung, LG, and Motorola, alleging infringement of U.S. Patent Nos. 7,881,393; 8,199,837; 8,576,940;...more

7/21/2016 - Apple Confidentiality Agreements Employment Contract IP Assignment Agreements LG Electronics Motorola Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Patent-in-Suit Samsung Standing

Recent Decision in Halo Requires Reconsideration of Summary Judgment Motion on Willfulness

In a multi-district litigation, the district court had previously granted summary judgment in favor of the defendants on the issue of willful infringement. After the Supreme Court's decision in Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse...more

7/19/2016 - Additional Discovery Enhanced Damages Halo v Pulse Motion for Reconsideration Multidistrict Litigation Patent Litigation Summary Judgment Vacated Willful Infringement

District Court Permits Survey Evidence to Support Lost Profits Damage Theory

The defendants', Roland DGA Corporation and Roland DG Corporation (collectively "Roland"), filed a motion for summary judgment against plaintiff, Gerber Scientific International, Inc. ("Gerber") regarding Gerber's claims for...more

7/15/2016 - Admissible Evidence But For Causation Damages Genuine Issue of Material Fact Gerber Lost Profits Motion for Summary Judgment Patent Infringement Surveys

District Court Denies Leave to Amend to Add Implied License Affirmative Defense Where Motion for Leave Was Filed Just Two Months...

Google, Inc. and YouTube, LLC (collectively "Google") filed a motion for leave to amend their answer to include an implied license affirmative defense. Because Google filed the motion to amend its answer more than two months...more

7/12/2016 - Affirmative Defenses Covenant Not to Sue Estoppel Google License Agreements Motion for Leave Patent Exhaustion Patent Infringement Patent Litigation YouTube

After Halo, District Court Concludes that Jury's Finding of Willfulness Is Still Appropriate

After a jury trial finding American Technical Ceramics Corp. ("ATC) willfully infringed Presidio Component's ("Presidio") patent, ATC filed a motion for a finding of no willful infringement based on the Supreme Court's...more

7/7/2016 - Enhanced Damages Halo v Pulse Jury Trial Jury Verdicts Patent Infringement Seagate Willful Infringement

After Inventor Dies, Patent Infringement Lawsuit Is Dismissed for Lack of Standing on Court's Own Motion

Chris Tavantzis and ChrisTrikes Custom Motorcycles, Inc. ("ChrisTrikes") filed a complaint against a number of individuals and entities that allegedly infringed on a patent for a wheelchair-accessible motorcycle (the...more

7/5/2016 - Article III Dismissals PATENT Act Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Standing Subject Matter Jurisdiction Successors

District Court Denies Agreed Upon Consent Judgment and Permanent Injunction Where Parties Failed to Submit Consent and Injunction...

After the parties settled the lawsuit, the district court dismissed the case without prejudice, subject to the right of any party to re-open the action within sixty days, upon good cause shown, or to submit a stipulated form...more

6/29/2016 - Motion to Dismiss Patent Litigation Permanent Injunctions Settlement Agreements Subject Matter Jurisdiction

District Court Declines Parties Joint Motion to Sever New Defendant from Pending Action

In this patent infringement action, the parties filed a joint motion to request that the district court sever Defendant Contour, LLC ("Contour") from the case. VStream, the plaintiff, had not effected service on Contour until...more

6/27/2016 - Case Consolidation Markman Hearing Motion To Sever Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Service of Process

After a Jury Trial Determining that the Defendant Infringed Several Valid Patents, the District Court Certified the Partial...

Plaintiffs asserted that defendants infringed several patents. The district court bifurcated liability and damages for all four patent infringement claims. After a jury trial, the jury concluded that the patents were valid...more

6/23/2016 - Bifurcation Damages Inter Partes Review Proceedings Jury Trial Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Patent Trial and Appeal Board Patents Rule 54(b)

Defendant's "Piecemeal" Approach to Discovery and Review of Only Select Files of Corporate Employees Results in Sanctions

In this patent infringement action, the defendants conducted a "piecemeal approach to discovery, reviewing only the files of select corporate employees." The district court found that this approach was contrary to the Federal...more

6/20/2016 - Attorney's Fees Discovery FRCP 26 Motion to Compel Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Sanctions

District Court Denies Request to Stay Discovery Pending Motion to Dismiss Based on Patent-Ineligible Subject Matter

J. Crew filed a motion to dismiss the plaintiffs' claims for patent infringement pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6), asserting that the patents-in-suit are drawn to patent-ineligible subject matter and...more

6/15/2016 - CLS Bank v Alice Corp Discovery Federal Rule 12(b)(6) J Crew Motion to Dismiss Motion To Stay Patent Infringement Patent-Eligible Subject Matter Section 101

District Court Denies Request for Order Compelling Production of Damage Expert Report from a Different Pending Case

In this patent infringement action between Chrimar Systems, Inc. ("Chrimar") and Alcatel-Lucent USA, Inc. ("Lucent"). Lucent sought production of the damages expert report of Plaintiffs' damages expert, Robert Mills, that was...more

6/14/2016 - Confidential Information Expert Testimony Motion to Compel Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Protective Orders Subpoenas

District Court May Preclude Evidence from Parent Company Where Parent Company Was Dismissed from Case and Then Refused to Provide...

When this patent infringement action began, the plaintiff explained that it was concerned that it would not be able to obtain important discovery if Ricoh Company Ltd. ("RCL"), which is the parent company of the defendants,...more

6/10/2016 - Discovery Japan Letters Rogatory Motion to Compel Order to Show Cause Parent Corporation Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Rule 30(b)(6)

As Part of Protective Order, District Court Orders Prosecution Bar and Covenant Not to Sue for New Patents Acquired by Patent...

In this patent infringement action, a dispute arose between Plaintiff Blackbird Tech LLC ("Blackbird") and the defendants over the terms of proposed protective orders to govern the use of confidential information produced....more

6/7/2016 - Confidential Information Corporate Counsel Covenant Not to Sue Inadvertent Disclosure Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Patent Portfolios Patent Prosecution Protective Orders

District Court Precludes Evidence of Patent Trial and Appeal Board's Denial of Institution of Inter Partes Review at Trial

As this patent infringement action proceeded to trial, Google filed a motion in limine to exclude evidence of Google's petitions for Inter Partes Review ("IPR") of claims of the patent-in-suit and the Patent Trial and Appeal...more

6/2/2016 - Evidence Google Inter Partes Review Proceedings Motion to Exclude Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Patent Trial and Appeal Board

District Court Strikes Infringement Contentions and Sanctioned Plaintiff for Taking Inconsistent Positions

The defendant, Echoworx, brought a motion to strike ZixCorp's infringement contentions. ZixCorp had served its original infringement contentions on Echoworx, contending that the elements of the patent-in-suit are software...more

5/31/2016 - Discovery Good Faith Motion To Strike Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Sanctions Software Source Code

District Court Strikes Documents That Were Not Produced During Discovery Even Though Documents Were Publically Available

In this patent infringement action, Mobile Telecommunications Tech., LLC ("MTel") filed against Blackberry Corp., MTel moved to exclude certain exhibits that were archived press releases published by RCR Wireless and SkyTel...more

5/25/2016 - Blackberry Duty to Disclose Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Motion To Strike Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Rule 26 Rule 37

Court Declines to Modify Judgment Based on Collateral Proceedings before the PTAB Finding Claims of Patent-In-Suit Invalid

Summary: In the decision referenced below, the court declined to modify a judgment pursuant to Rule 60(b)(6) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure even though the PTAB had found several claims of the patent-in-suit...more

5/23/2016 - Administrative Proceedings Article III Damages Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Patent Invalidity Patent Royalties Patent Trial and Appeal Board Patent-in-Suit Summary Judgment

Failure to Institute Inter Partes Review Is Not Grounds for Common Law Estoppel to Prevent Defendant from Re-Litigating Issues...

The defendant filed a petition for Inter Partes Review ("IPR") with the Patent Office. As part of its application, it submitted a 65 page brief along with several hundred pages of accompanying evidence. The plaintiffs...more

5/19/2016 - Administrative Boards Collateral Estoppel Final Judgment Inter Partes Review Proceedings Patent Litigation

District Court Grants Permanent Injunction after Summary Judgment Ruling in Favor of Patent Holder Where Defendant Was Direct...

After the district court granted the plaintiff's motion for summary judgment of patent infringement, the district court addressed whether a permanent injunction was appropriate. The patent at issue, U.S. Patent No. 6,065,794...more

5/16/2016 - Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Permanent Injunctions

District Court Refuses to Recognize "Apex" Doctrine for Documents Created by Inventor and Global Leader of Company

The defendant filed a motion to compel, seeking a wide array of discovery against Plaintiffs Dyson, Inc. and Dyson Limited (collectively, "Plaintiffs") to produce emails belonging to James Dyson ("Dyson"). Plaintiffs asserted...more

5/11/2016 - Apex Doctrine Burden of Proof Claim Construction Discovery Document Productions Motion to Compel Patent Infringement Patent Litigation

Experts Ordered to Produce Draft Reports Exchanged with Other Experts

In this patent infringement action, the plaintiff, BRP, alleged three counts of patent infringement against Arctic Cat concerning snowmobile frame construction and snowmobile rider positioning. BRP alleged patent infringement...more

5/9/2016 - Discovery Expert Witness Patent Infringement Patent Litigation Patents

District Court Denies Request to Have Invalidity Case Proceed Prior to Infringement Case

The parties in this patent infringement action could not agree on the order of proof at trial. Defendants sought to present their invalidity defense first, arguing that if the patent is invalid, they could not be liable for...more

5/6/2016 - Affirmative Defenses Burden of Proof Judicial Discretion Jury Instructions Noninfringement Patent Infringement Patent Invalidity Patent Litigation

337 Results
View per page
Page: of 14

"My best business intelligence, in one easy email…"

Your first step to building a free, personalized, morning email brief covering pertinent authors and topics on JD Supra:

Sign up to create your digest using LinkedIn*

*By using the service, you signify your acceptance of JD Supra's Privacy Policy.

Already signed up? Log in here

*With LinkedIn, you don't need to create a separate login to manage your free JD Supra account, and we can make suggestions based on your needs and interests. We will not post anything on LinkedIn in your name. Or, sign up using your email address.