On Jan. 20, 2016, a federal district court in the Western District of Texas affirmed a decision of the Medical Appeals Council (Appeals Council) affirming a CMS contractor’s extrapolation methodology used to assess an overpayment of more than $773,000 from a home health provider, Maxmed. Three key takeaways from the Court’s decision that may help health care providers avoid a similar situation include:

1. Providers should be keenly aware of the rules limiting CMS’s participation as a party to an appeal when devising their appeal strategies, and its subsequent ability to appeal the ALJ decision on its own. Similarly, they should be aware of the Medicare Appeals Council’s ability to review any ALJ decision or dismissal on its own motion, or with referral from CMS...