A Tax Opinion that Didn’t Carry the Day.


The Fifth Circuit recently applied the economic substance doctrine to a transaction involving foreign currency straddles, sustaining the government’s position.

While the Court’s analysis of the economic substance seems solid, its treatment of the good faith defense to a negligence penalty troubles me a bit. My concern is that the Court apparently views the sufficiency of a tax opinion to be a fact question, even though that requires the application of law (regulations governing the sufficiency of tax opinions) to fact.

LOADING PDF: If there are any problems, click here to download the file.

Published In: Tax Updates