California Court Tentatively Holds 50% Tax Shelter Promotion Penalty Cannot Apply Retroactively


A San Francisco Superior Court has released a tentative statement of decision, holding that the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) could not retroactively apply an increased penalty rate for tax shelter promotion activities.1 In Quellos Financial Advisors, LLC v. Franchise Tax Board,2 the court held that the statute authorizing the increased penalty rate did not provide for, and California case law did not allow, the FTB to apply the increased rate retroactively.

The statute at issue in Quellos was section 19177.3 For the taxable years at issue in Quellos, section 19177 conformed to Internal Revenue Code (IRC) section 6700, which provided for a maximum penalty of $1,000 for promoting abusive tax shelters. On October 2, 2003 (and after the tax years at issue in Quellos), California amended section 191774 to replace the maximum penalty of $1,000 with a new maximum penalty of 50 percent of the gross income derived from the penalized activity. For all other purposes, section 19177 continued to conform to IRC section 6700.5

The bill that enacted the increased maximum penalty stated, "this act shall apply with respect to any penalty assessed on or after January 1, 2004, on any return for which the statute of limitations on assessment has not expired. All other provisions of this act shall apply on and after January 1, 2004."6 It is important to note that the bill enacted or revised several assessable penalties in addition to the penalty on tax promoters.

Please see full alert below for more information.

LOADING PDF: If there are any problems, click here to download the file.

Published In: Tax Updates