Denunciation, Deterrence and Retribution: Jury Awards Dismissed Employee $573,000 in Punitive Damages

more+
less-

[author: Dana Hooker]

The Vancouver Sun has reported that a British Columbia jury recently awarded employee Larry Higginson over half a million dollars in punitive damages, on top of a $236,000 award for wrongful dismissal, taking damages flowing from a wrongful dismissal to new heights in Higginson v. Babine Forest Products Ltd. and Hampton Lumber Mills Inc.

The Jury decision is not reported, however according to reports, Mr. Higginson had been employed for 34 years with the Defendant, Babine Forest Products Ltd., until he was dismissed on October 14, 2009, apparently for just cause. The employer alleged that Mr. Higginson failed to perform his duties as a manager. In response, Mr. Higginson alleged that cause had not been established and that the employer had set him up for termination of employment, had made his working environment miserable and had alleged cause to avoid the obligation to pay notice of termination of employment to long-term employees.

The Prince George B.C. jury found that the employer did not have cause to terminate his employment, and awarded damages in excess of $800,000 as a result of the wrongful dismissal.

Such a large punitive damages award has not been seen since the 2008 Ontario Superior Court of Justice awarded $500,000 to a wrongfully dismissed employee in Keays v. Honda Canada Inc. However, in Keays, the Supreme Court of Canada (2008 SCC 39) overturned the punitive damages award on appeal.

A Notice of Appeal was filed in Higginson on July 18, 2012.