Insurance Law Update - Negligent Design and Construction Is Not an Occurrence of Property Damage - February 2011


U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit

In VRV Development L.P.v. Mid-Continent Cas. Co., ___ F.3d ___, 2011 WL 48897 (5th Cir. (Tex.) January 7, 2011), the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals held that negligent design and construction is not an “occurrence” that resulted in “property damage” within the meaning of a commercial general liability (CGL) policy issued by Mid-Continent Casualty Company to VRV Development L.P. As such, the court concluded that Mid-Continent had no duty to defend or indemnify VRV for a lawsuit alleging property damage resulting from the collapse of retaining walls constructed by VRV, when the collapse occurred after the policy periods.

Mid-Continent’s policy was effective from May 25, 2004 to May 25, 2005, and renewed through May 25, 2006. In 2004, VRV hired subcontractors to design and build retaining walls on residential lots. A homeowner’s inspection between May and July 2006 identified a crack in one of the retaining walls. In January and March 2007, after periods of heavy rainfall – and after the policy expired – the retaining walls collapsed. The homeowners sued VRV and Mid-Continent denied VRV’s tender of defense and indemnity.

In VRV’s ensuing coverage action, the district court granted summary judgment for Mid-Continent and the Fifth Circuit affirmed.

Please see full article below for more information.

LOADING PDF: If there are any problems, click here to download the file.