On December 9, 2014, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) issued final decisions in three inter partes review (IPR) proceedings filed by Amneal Pharmaceuticals challenging three patents listed in the Orange Book for Oracea® (doxycycline). In each case, the PTAB found that Amneal had not proved by a preponderance of the evidence that the challenged claims were unpatentable. These decisions represent the first IPR Final Decision on an Orange Book-listed patent since the enactment of the America Invents Act.
Amneal filed three IPR petitions in June 2013 challenging certain claims of US Patent Nos. 8,394,406, 8,206,740 and 8,394,405 as obvious. In September 2013, the patent owner Supernus filed responses requesting the PTAB deny the petitions. Supernus highlighted, inter alia, that the prior art relied on by Amneal was cited to the examiner during prosecution of each of the challenged patents and that a district court previously upheld the validity of the parent patent under the same combinations of prior art asserted by Amneal. In December 2013, the PTAB instituted each of the IPRs, finding Amneal "established a reasonable likelihood that it would prevail" on one of the four grounds raised in their petitions. (See, e.g., IPR2013-00368, Decision to Institute Inter Partes Review, p. 13.) The parties then proceeded through the expedited IPR discovery period. Ultimately, because the IPRs were instituted on the same ground for each of the three patents, a consolidated oral argument for all three IPR proceedings was conducted in August 2014.
Please see full publication below for more information.