On February 1, 2012, “smart journal” application provider, Path, Inc. (“Path”) agreed to settle Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) charges that it deceived consumers and improperly collected personal information in violation of the FTC Act and the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (“COPPA”). Mobile platforms and application providers should take note of this settlement and the underlying charges in order to avoid potentially onerous fines associated with such privacy violations.
Path describes its social networking service as a way to “keep a personal journal, or ‘Path’, of your life.” Through the “Path App”, a user can upload, store and share photos, written journal entries, current locations and songs. The FTC initiated its action against Path in February of 2012, taking issue with the method by which Path was collecting and storing personal data. Specifically, the FTC pointed to the “Add Friends” feature that provided users with three options: “Find friends from your contacts; “Find friends from Facebook;” and “Invite friends to join Path by email or SMS.” Regardless of whether the user elected to “Add Friends,” Path automatically collected the first name, last name, address, phone number, email address, Facebook username, Twitter username and date of birth for each contact in the user’s mobile device address book. According to the FTC’s complaint, “the user had no meaningful choice as to the collection and storage of personal information from the user’s mobile device contacts, and the user interface options were illusory.” In addition, the FTC argued that Path knowingly accepted registrations from approximately 3,000 children under the age of 13, without first obtaining parental consent, and collected personal information for each contact in the child registrant’s mobile device address book.
The settlement requires Path to establish a “comprehensive privacy program” and to obtain independent privacy assessments every other year for the next 20 years. Path is also prohibited from making any misrepresentation about the extent to which it maintains the privacy and confidentiality of consumers’ personal information and must delete information collected from children under the age of 13. Perhaps most importantly, Path must pay $800,000 to settle the COPPA charges.
For a relatively new startup like Path, the $800,000 fine is a significant deterrent measure and signals the FTC’s serious commitment to consumer, especially child consumer, privacy. It is no mistake the FTC announced this settlement on the same day that it released guidelines on how to improve mobile privacy disclosures. Accordingly, mobile developers should look to this settlement, and the underlying charges, as a touchstone going forward.