The Case For a Broad Pre-Emption Rule for CERCLA Contribution


Although some of the proposed tax plans and budgets being discussed in this election year suggest that the same dollar can be counted and spent multiple times, a growing number of courts have held that CERCLA response costs can only be allocated once. The most recent holding comes in the Lower Fox River litigation where Judge Greisbach ruled that CERCLA pre-empts most ancillary state law claims – whether styled as state law contribution claims or common law claims for negligence and strict liability: “If the funds were expended pursuant to CERCLA, and if CERCLA itself provides a scheme for reapportioning those funds, then allowing a state law claim to essentially re-reapportion those funds in a way CERCLA did not intend would pose a conflict.”

Affording CERCLA contribution proceedings broad pre-emption makes good sense.  Whenever the damages being sought in an ancillary claim are the functional equivalent of CERCLA response costs, that ancillary claim should be pre-empted since the same response cost cannot be given alternative allocations. Such a broad pre-emption rule would still permit a party to pursue a state law property damages claim provided that that claim will not be cured by a CERCLA response action. Such a rule would also permit state law claims brought by innocent parties that are not themselves PRPs since those parties are not subject to having their damages apportioned by a CERCLA contribution claim.


Perhaps most importantly, a broad pre-emption rule for CERCLA contribution actions provides meaningful protection to CERCLA settling parties.  While CERCLA settling parties get complete protection from CERCLA contribution claims under Section 113(f)(3), that protection would be illusory if non-settling parties could circumvent it merely by re-casting their claims as state law contribution or common law claims.


Written by:

Published In:

DISCLAIMER: Because of the generality of this update, the information provided herein may not be applicable in all situations and should not be acted upon without specific legal advice based on particular situations.

© Foley Hoag LLP - Environmental Law | Attorney Advertising

Don't miss a thing! Build a custom news brief:

Read fresh new writing on compliance, cybersecurity, Dodd-Frank, whistleblowers, social media, hiring & firing, patent reform, the NLRB, Obamacare, the SEC…

…or whatever matters the most to you. Follow authors, firms, and topics on JD Supra.

Create your news brief now - it's free and easy »

All the intelligence you need, in one easy email:

Great! Your first step to building an email digest of JD Supra authors and topics. Log in with LinkedIn so we can start sending your digest...

Sign up for your custom alerts now, using LinkedIn ›

* With LinkedIn, you don't need to create a separate login to manage your free JD Supra account, and we can make suggestions based on your needs and interests. We will not post anything on LinkedIn in your name.