Tie Goes To The...


Most people know the baseball saying that “a tie goes to the runner.”  But who wins if there is a tie in the votes of the judges who are deciding an appellate matter?  This article addresses how a case can have a tie vote on appeal and the effect of a tie on the parties.


How Ties Happen On Appeal

Most decisions on the merits in appeals are heard by a panel of judges.  The panel is usually composed of an odd number of judges.  For example, in the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court and Pennsylvania Superior Court, cases are usually decided by panels of three judges.  For certain cases that are deemed to have important issues, the Commonwealth Court and Superior Court will have larger panels (known as an en banc panel), which also have an odd number of judges.   In the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, decisions are made by the entire Court, which is statutorily designated to have seven justices.


After a case is briefed and argued on appeal, the judges on the panel meet to vote on the outcome.  Obviously, if there is an odd number of judges considering the case the vote cannot be tied.  But sometimes, a judge who has heard the case cannot participate in the decision due to a conflict of interest that emerges requiring recusal or an illness or some other reason that prevents participation.  The Pennsylvania Supreme Court recently had only six justices sitting due to the suspension of Justice Joan Orie Melvin (she has now resigned and Judge Correale F. Stevens is joining the Supreme Court bench).  Justice Orie Melvin’s absence resulted in some tie decisions in the Supreme Court.  See, e.g., Alkhafaji v. TIAA-CREF Individual and Institutional Servs., LLC, 38 WAP 2011 & 39 WAP 2011 (consolidated cases – similar issues) (decided June 17, 2013); Commonwealth v. Champney, 574 CAP & 575 CAP (consolidated cases – cross-appeals) (decided April 24, 2013).


Efforts To Break The Tie

If there is a tie vote, in an effort to break the tie, the judges can agree to reconsider the issues and perhaps change their view on the correct outcome of the case.  Or, the judges could agree to narrow the focus of the ruling such that the area where there is a disagreement is not addressed.  The courts’ internal operating provisions can also address how a tie vote is handled.  For example, in the Commonwealth Court, where a tie occurs as a result of a recusal or vacancy after a draft opinion is circulating, the opinion will be filed as circulated notwithstanding the later occurring tie.  See Section 256(b) of the Internal Operating Procedures of the Commonwealth Court, 210 Pa. Code § 67.29(b).


Who Wins If There Is A Tie

If the tie is not broken, the result from the court below is upheld.  So the appellant loses on appeal and the appellee wins (here is a useful mnemonic device to remember which party is the appellant and which is the appellee:  the appellant  brings the appeal -- picture an ant bringing a breadcrumb in its mandibles up the anthill).  In Champney, both parties lost, because they had filed cross-appeals which were consolidated.  The tie vote in that case had the effect of upholding the entirety of the Superior Court decision, so neither party was able to achieve any relief on appeal. 


As a result, when there is a tie in the votes of the appellate judges, the opportunity to correct, clarify or change the decision or the law is lost.  And, unfortunately, the parties will have expended time, effort and fees on appeal for naught.


DISCLAIMER: Because of the generality of this update, the information provided herein may not be applicable in all situations and should not be acted upon without specific legal advice based on particular situations.

© McNees Wallace & Nurick LLC | Attorney Advertising

Written by:


McNees Wallace & Nurick LLC on:

Readers' Choice 2017
Reporters on Deadline

"My best business intelligence, in one easy email…"

Your first step to building a free, personalized, morning email brief covering pertinent authors and topics on JD Supra:

Sign up to create your digest using LinkedIn*

*By using the service, you signify your acceptance of JD Supra's Privacy Policy.

Already signed up? Log in here

*With LinkedIn, you don't need to create a separate login to manage your free JD Supra account, and we can make suggestions based on your needs and interests. We will not post anything on LinkedIn in your name. Or, sign up using your email address.