Troy Smith allegedly masturbated in public view of others on three separate occasions. Two separate groups of people claim they saw this.

In the third incident, Mary Hernandez allegedly was standing in her house and looked out the window to see Smith masturbating in her backyard. Ms. Hernandez quickly closed the curtains. A few minutes later, Hernandez’s sixteen year old daughter entered the room and opened the windows, only to see Smith still standing in her backyard in the same location, masturbating. She then turned away.