Can You Be Sued if You Wave Another Driver to Go Ahead?

The Brown Firm
Contact

The Brown Firm

We've all been there. 

We're sitting in rush hour traffic, and it's been bumper to bumper for what feels like hours. 

Now a person in on-coming traffic wants to make a left in front of your car. 

So, you decide to be helpful. You aren't going anywhere anyway.

So you stop, and you don't move forward in traffic when the car in front of you does, opening a path for the person wanting to make a left across both lanes of on-coming traffic. 

You give a polite wave to the person letting them know they can cross in front of you.

But, there's a car traveling in the lane to your right that doesn't see the turning car, and the turning car doesn't see it. 

So the driver making the left doesn't see the car, turns in front of it, and gets t-boned. 

You can't be sued or held responsible for this accident, can you? You were just trying to be nice.

In the article below, we will talk about your responsibility in a car accident if you deice to wave a car through.

Related article: How to protect your legal rights after a car accident

Waving Another Driver Forward

Everyone has waved another driver on at one time or another.

It happens all the time at intersections or in heavy traffic. 

You've noticed a poor soul who wants to find a break in the traffic and make his or her way home from work, so you decide to help them out. 

You stop your car and give a little wave, letting the other driver know they can move ahead.

This might make you a nice person. The other driver is undoubtedly grateful, but this also opens you up to legal liability. 

If another car comes along and drives ahead after you wave a driver on, hitting the car you just waved into traffic, you could be held partially responsible for the accident.

When juries are looking at car accidents, they have to consider whether or not a defendant has any legal duty of care in a situation. 

Every time you get behind the wheel of your car, you have a duty of care to be a responsible driver.

If you wave another driver through, a jury may decide that you voluntarily took on some additional responsibility for another driver when you waved them into traffic.

Some states use comparative negligence, which means that juries have to decide precisely how much each party in an accident is responsible. 

These cases often aren't easy to resolve and could result in a lot of legal wrangling in court.

Unfortunately, there's only one way to make sure you aren't held liable for an accident. 

Even if it goes against your instincts, and that driver has been waiting to turn for a while, don't try to help them out by waving him or her into traffic.

If the roles are ever reversed, don't accept another driver's wave as assurance that the way is really clear.

Nodle Brothers vs. Wray

In 1980, the Virginia Supreme court adopted a principle from the Nolde Brothers v. Wray trial.

During the trial, the court stated found that, "If a driver's waving signal was or could be interpreted to another driver as a signal to proceed across lanes of incoming traffic, then the driver who waves has to be certain the other driver can cross safely." 

The court reasoned that the driver who received the wave was able to see that the other driver was not positioned to see whether there were any vehicles in the other lanes of traffic.

Ten years later, the Virginia Supreme Court confronted the waving issue again.  

In Ring v. Poelman, a driver in the left lane of traffic struck a car that pulled out in front of it. 

The car came from behind a line of traffic stopped in the right lane.  

The driver of the car pulling out claimed that the stopped driver in the right lane waved him out.  

But unlike Nolde Brothers v. Wray, the court found that the driver giving the signal "was positioned that the jury reasonably could find that he could have and should have seen the danger of traffic approaching from the rear in the left turn lane."

If that was true, and the jury found that the driver being waved out reasonably believed that the wave was a signal to proceed into the left turn lane, the waving driver would have been found liable.

If you ever wave another car in front of you, you could be found liable if an accident or injury occurs. 

Even though it seems like a nice thing to do, you do not want your well-intentioned actions to lead to an accident and injuries. 

If you want to help, avoid making a wave. 

You can leave a gap, giving them the option to go through, but don't make eye contact or wave people in because you may be held liable.

Waving someone through can indicate that it's safe, which means you're assuming liability.

Drivers who wave another car in front of them could be found liable if a car accident occurs. 

Helping someone through traffic can feel like a nice thing to do, but you never want your well-intentioned actions to lead to an accident. 

The best advice in these situations is to never wave someone into traffic. 

As mentioned above, you can leave a gap and let them in, but never make eye contact or wave people in.

Waving or gesturing can indicate that it's safe, which then means you're taking on a duty/responsibility.

If you've recently been involved in a car accident that involved one driver waving another driver into traffic, you should contact a car accident attorney.

The Original Article Is Here

DISCLAIMER: Because of the generality of this update, the information provided herein may not be applicable in all situations and should not be acted upon without specific legal advice based on particular situations.

© The Brown Firm | Attorney Advertising

Written by:

The Brown Firm
Contact
more
less

The Brown Firm on:

Reporters on Deadline

"My best business intelligence, in one easy email…"

Your first step to building a free, personalized, morning email brief covering pertinent authors and topics on JD Supra:
*By using the service, you signify your acceptance of JD Supra's Privacy Policy.
Custom Email Digest
- hide
- hide

This website uses cookies to improve user experience, track anonymous site usage, store authorization tokens and permit sharing on social media networks. By continuing to browse this website you accept the use of cookies. Click here to read more about how we use cookies.