News: “Why One-Size-Fits-All Individual Attorney Business Plans Fail Lawyers and How to Build Plans That Reflect Strengths, Not Templates,” The Legal Intelligencer

Poston Communications
Contact

Effective business plans for lawyers are personalized while reflecting a firm’s culture. They recognize, for example, that a woman partner faces different dynamics than her male counterpart, an associate’s objectives are fundamentally different from an equity partner’s, and a regulatory lawyer builds a practice differently than a litigator.

Law firms routinely tell lawyers they need business plans. Annual and compensation reviews demand them. Practice group leaders and overall firm best practices require them. Marketing and business development teams are asked to develop and support them. Yet too often, the plans themselves are formulaic, underutilized or quietly ignored once they are submitted. The problem is that many firms treat them as a template or interchangeable when in actuality, ONE SIZE DOES NOT FIT ALL. A single template is often distributed across the firm, regardless of seniority, career path, practice, personality, gender or diversity.

The results are predictable: Plans that are not tailored to the individual lawyer most often fail.
Effective business plans for lawyers are personalized while reflecting a firm’s culture. They recognize, for example, that a woman partner faces different dynamics than her male counterpart, an associate’s objectives are fundamentally different from an equity partner’s, and a regulatory lawyer builds a practice differently than a litigator. They also account for the necessary consideration of the individual-their personality, communication style and level of comfort with business development.

“Before you start your business plan, it’s important to understand the culture of your firm and practice group,” said Michael Coston, founder of Coston Consulting, a business advisory firm that specializes in helping law firms improve their business generation, talent development and culture.

“When you understand your culture, you can align your personal goals with the organization’s priorities and focus on opportunities that are of high importance. Without that lens, you risk investing significant time and effort where it may not be supported, valued or rewarded.”

Start with Strengths and Goals-Based Strategy Rather Than Tactics

A lawyer’s personalized business plan should answer three questions: Who do I want to work with, how will I build visibility and credibility with those audiences, and what actions will I take this year to move closer to that goal? The answers vary dramatically from lawyer to lawyer.

Many plans fail because they begin with activities rather than strategy. Lawyers are told to list speaking engagements, client alerts or networking events without first assessing whether those activities make sense for their role, practice or strengths.

Furthermore, those tactics may not even target the correct audiences to reach their personal goals.

Plans also fail if they set an unrealistic time span or expectation of when elements will be pursued. Individualized plans do not require starting from scratch each time. Developing plans with different flexible modules works best.

They apply a consistent framework while allowing for adjustments that consider the primary differentiators.

Gender Differences Matter in Business Development

Women lawyers still navigate business development differently than men. A business plan that ignores these realities is incomplete. This does not mean women should be held to different standards; it simply means designing and relying on plans that play to their strengths. Many women excel at collaborative client development and cross-selling. Business plans should support those approaches rather than forcing conformity to a standardized checklist of must-dos.

At the same time, women lawyers can profit from strategies that emphasize visibility through expertise rather than purely relationship-driven approaches. Thought leadership, speaking opportunities and targeted media placements can be used in business plans to position women as authorities, making them less reliant on traditional networking channels to open doors.

In her recently published book “Breaking Ground-How Successful Women Lawyers Build Thriving Practices” (Practising Law Institute, 2026), Deborah B. Farone interviewed dozens of high achieving women attorneys about their business development successes.

“It’s essential for all lawyers, both men and women, to find ways to market themselves in ways that feel appropriate and authentic. Clients can tell if a lawyer who doesn’t like sports invites them to a tennis match. By finding those shared interests that you have with a client, and focusing on the activities that you also like, it becomes much more comfortable to develop relationships. You are much more likely to stick to a plan when you look forward to the activities that support it,” Farone writes.

Associates, Partners and Equity Partners Need Different Plans

Treating business planning as a uniform exercise across seniority levels is a common and costly mistake. While every lawyer should understand how relationships and reputation contribute to long-term success, the focus and expectations of a business plan must evolve as lawyers advance.

For junior associates, the emphasis should be on developing excellent lawyering skills first. Business plans for junior lawyers should be light-touch and realistic, centered on foundation building rather than origination. Goals may include increasing internal visibility; learning client industries; and maintaining relationships with law school, college and early professional contacts. Asking junior associates to “build a book” too early can be distracting and counterproductive.

Senior associates require a more deliberate but still measured shift toward business development. Their plans should reflect growing confidence and credibility while continuing to prioritize strong legal performance. Objectives may include deepening relationships and taking on greater responsibility within client teams; refining a niche or industry focus; and becoming visible externally through writing, speaking or targeted networking. At this stage, business development is about positioning and momentum, not immediate revenue generation.

For nonequity partners, business plans need to consider growth and must include measurable success. Effective plans identify specific client and industry targets, outline cross-selling opportunities and clarify what progress toward equity partnership actually looks like.

Equity partners require the most sophisticated and accountable planning. Their plans should reflect leadership responsibilities, revenue generation, client development strategies, talent development and succession planning. At this level, business plans are not just personal roadmaps; they are tools for sustaining and growing the firm.

“Business planning should evolve with a lawyer’s career,” says Rebecca Hnatowski, founder of Edwards Advisory. “For associates, it’s about fundamentals-mastering their subject matter and developing relationships early. For new partners, the focus shifts to leading more substantial business discussions with clients and building relationships across practices. And for senior partners, planning often includes succession and ensuring relationships outlast any one individual.”

Practice Area Differences Shape Business Development

Not all practices grow the same way. A corporate lawyer building a private equity practice will rely on different strategies than a white-collar litigator or regulatory adviser. A tax attorney and a product liability attorney will have quite different growth opportunities.

Transactional practices often depend on relationship-driven deal flow and intermediaries. Litigation practices rely more heavily on reputation, referrals and experience. Regulatory and niche practices frequently grow through education, visibility and timely thought leadership tied to emerging issues.

When firms rigidly apply identical business planning expectations across all practices, they are doomed to fail. Effective plans account for deal cycles, client decision-making processes, current market factors, trending litigation and competitive landscapes specific to each practice area.

Different Plans, Shared Accountability and Recognition

Business planning should evolve as lawyers progress, but it should never exist in a vacuum. Firms that expect thoughtful and differentiated plans must also reinforce the behavior they want to see.
Firms should celebrate success and consistently make space at partner meetings, practice group meetings and industry team discussions to talk about new matters and how relationships were developed. Publicly recognizing lawyers who bring in new work reinforces that business development matters, demystifies the process and signals that effort is noticed and valued.

These conversations turn abstract business development expectations into practical lessons others can learn from.

And when firms align realistic and role-appropriate business plans with visible reinforcement and recognition, business development becomes part of the culture rather than just another administrative exercise.

Reprinted with permission from the March 10, 2026 edition of The Legal Intelligencer © 2025 ALM Media Properties, LLC. All rights reserved.

[View source.]

Written by:

Poston Communications
Contact
more
less

PUBLISH YOUR CONTENT ON JD SUPRA

  • Increased readership
  • Actionable analytics
  • Ongoing writing guidance

Join more than 70,000 authors publishing their insights on JD Supra

Start Publishing »

Poston Communications on:

Reporters on Deadline

"My best business intelligence, in one easy email…"

Your first step to building a free, personalized, morning email brief covering pertinent authors and topics on JD Supra:
*By using the service, you signify your acceptance of JD Supra's Privacy Policy.
Custom Email Digest
- hide
- hide