Our Agricultural Legislative & Public Policy Team examines another pair of proposed rules that would reform the H-2A program.
- DOL and DHS assert the rules are intended to protect temporary agricultural workers and enhance agencies’ ability to monitor compliance
- But they could bring delays, higher costs, and work disruptions for employers
- The comment periods for both proposed rules end in November
The H-2A temporary agricultural program – administered by the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL), Department of Homeland Security (DHS), and State Department – allows agricultural employers that anticipate a shortage of domestic workers to bring nonimmigrant foreign workers to the United States to perform agricultural labor or services on a temporary or seasonal basis.
Due to instability in the domestic workforce, the use of seasonal nonimmigrant programs has become vital to ensuring businesses can have an adequate supply of labor. The H-2A program has expanded significantly in recent years. Similarly, applications for the H-2B program have well exceeded its statutory cap of 66,000 visas. In the H-2A program, the DOL reports over 302,000 certified positions for H-2A workers through the 3rd quarter of Fiscal Year 2023. Through the entire Fiscal Year 2020, there were only 275,430 certifications. During this same time frame, employers have been hit with multiple rulemakings changing the rules of the program.
In recent weeks, the Biden Administration has issued yet another series of proposed rulemakings that would incorporate further reforms to the H-2A program. The DOL and DHS assert that the proposed reforms are intended to strengthen protections for temporary agricultural workers and enhance federal agencies’ capabilities to monitor program compliance and take necessary enforcement actions against program violators. Regardless, employers will likely see administrative delays, higher costs, work disruptions, and increased enforcement activity.
The series of regulatory proposals include:
1. Department of Labor Proposed Rule: Improving Protections for Workers in Temporary Agricultural Employment in the United States; RIN 1205-AC12 [DOL Docket No. ETA-2023-0003]. Comments are due November 14, 2023.
DOL proposes to:
- Remove the 14-day payroll implementation window for changes in the adverse effect wage rate.
- Expand labor organizations’ access to the H-2A program and corresponding workers’ private information and ability to access private employer property.
- Require public disclosure of names of all agents and foreign labor recruiters used by employers.
- Provide the DOL with greater authority to initiate enforcement actions against employers that allegedly violate the program rules.
- Shorten the period to file rebuttal evidence or request a hearing upon service of notice of debarment from 30 calendar days to 14 calendar days.
2. Department of Homeland Security Proposed Rule: Modernizing H-2 Program Requirements, Oversight, and Worker Protections; RIN 1615-AC76 [DHS Docket No. USCIS-2023-0012]. Comments are due November 20, 2023.
DHS proposes to:
- Provide DHS additional authority to deny or revoke petitions based upon failure to comply with H-2A and H-2B program requirements, violation of labor laws, or charging workers prohibited fees.
- Create whistleblower protection for H-2A and H-2B employees.
- Modify worker grace periods to 10 days before the petition’s validity period, up to 30 days following its expiration, and up to 60 days if the H-2A or H-2B worker was terminated or resigned or if a petition has been revoked.
- Allow an H-2A or H-2B worker to discontinue employment and begin new employment, within the same classification, immediately upon the proper filing of a new petition.
- Shorten the period of absence to reset the three-year limit of stay to an uninterrupted 60 days.
Given the Administration’s recent efforts regarding the H-2A program, these proposals are not unexpected. However, due to the two previous rulemakings, farmers are already struggling to comply with complex regulatory burdens and rising costs of the H-2A program. These proposed rules only add layers of complexity and the risks of unintentional errors.
The comment period is currently open for both proposed rules. This is a critical window for stakeholders and agricultural employers to provide input as the Administration considers potential revisions to the final rule.
Download PDF of Advisory