Decision Date: May 8, 2013 and June 3, 2014 Court: W.D. Virginia -
Patent: D448,541 -
Holding: Plaintiff’s motion for reconsideration of order denying preliminary injunction -
DENIED. Defendant’s motion for fees DENIED.
Opinion:
Plaintiff Charles Robinson sued JoeyBra LLC in May 2012 for infringement of U.S. Design Patent No. D448,541 entitled “Brassiere.” Robinson obtained a patent for his pocketed bra design in 2001. JoeyBra’s product, the JoeyBra, is also a pocketed bra intended to hold phones, IDs, keys, and other small items. This opinion addresses Robinson’s motion for reconsideration following the court’s denial of a motion for preliminary injunction on the basis that Robinson was not likely to succeed on the merits. Robinson claimed the court erred in its likelihood of success determination in two respects: (1) it relied on a 2010 patent of a pocketed bra design to determine that his patent was likely not novel, and thus invalid; and (2) it determined that the JoeyBra design was substantially different than the patented design.
To invalidate a patent based on novelty, a court must rely only on prior art references which were available before the patent’s filing date....
Please see full publication below for more information.