Negligence in Preserving ESI Warrants Monetary Sanctions

by Zapproved LLC

N.M. Oncology & Hematology Consultants v. Presbyterian Healthcare Servs., No. 1:12-cv-00526 (D.N.M. Aug. 16, 2017).

Because the defendant was merely negligent in producing discoverable information, the magistrate judge recommended only that it pay 75% of the costs of the plaintiff’s motion for sanctions.

This antitrust case began when the plaintiff, New Mexico Oncology and Hematology Consultants, Ltd. (“NMOHC”), filed its complaint on May 16, 2012. Six days later, the defendant, Presbyterian Healthcare Services (“PHS”), issued its first legal hold. That hold went to 35 employees, directing them to “make diligent and reasonable efforts to preserve responsive documents” that related to “an expansive list” of subjects. Through referrals, PHS added several individuals to the original hold. In March 2013, PHS sent an “updated litigation hold” to 174 more individuals.

In this motion, NMOHC asked the court to sanction PHS for failing to implement a “proper” legal hold and for intentionally deleting emails.

Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37, courts may sanction a party that failed to take reasonable steps to preserve — and consequently lost — electronically stored information (ESI). Courts may enter severe spoliation sanctions only if a party intentionally destroyed ESI to prevent another party from using it.

As to the litigation hold, the magistrate noted that litigants need not preserve all ESI or “every shred of paper.” NMOHC argued that PHS gave its employees too much discretion in determining what might be relevant. However, PHS’s legal hold directed employees “unsure” of documents’ relevancy to “be cautious and preserve” them. The magistrate found this “limited discretion” permissible.

NMOHC also argued that PHS continued, despite the legal hold, to enforce its “email jail.” The “email jail” required employees to delete or archive emails when their inboxes grew too large. However, no PHS employees testified that they deleted relevant emails because of the email jail. Nor did they believe that the email jail superseded the legal hold.

NMOHC next pointed to PHS’s late addition of “important witnesses” to the hold. Here, the magistrate was “unpersuaded that either [of the named omitted witnesses] was a ‘key player.’” Notably, NMOHC “chose not to depose either witness even after learning that they had been excluded” from the initial hold.

In all, the magistrate agreed that PHS’s legal hold was imperfect. However, he concluded that NMOHC had not demonstrated that PHS implemented it in bad faith or that it caused any spoliation.

NMOHC further alleged that PHS “intentionally deleted discoverable emails” that Dr. Dava Gerard sent or received. NMOHC claimed data errors in Gerard’s PST file and in the unallocated space of the backup hard drive indicated corruption or deletion.

In a surprise twist, PHS’s sloppy procedures in backing up its data were its saving grace. PHS failed to follow accepted best practices, such as documenting its collection process or using a forensically sound copy process. The magistrate concluded that PHS might also not have used a clean hard drive for the Gerard PST export. According to the log, there was “a massive error” in that export that could explain the irregular data.

Therefore, NMOHC did not establish by a preponderance of evidence that PHS intentionally deleted Gerard’s emails. Rather, the magistrate found that “while the errors in collection were either avoidable or immediately rectifiable, they were unintentional.”

The magistrate concluded that, despite PHS’s “many mistakes,” the company “did not act in bad faith.” Therefore, the rules permitted neither a default judgment or an adverse inference jury instruction.

But PHS was negligent in producing ESI. That “negligence resulted in many of the errors in producing ESI, which caused [NMOHC] to believe the instant motion to be necessary.” Accordingly, the magistrate recommended that PHS be ordered to pay 75% of NMOHC’s costs in bringing this motion for sanctions.

Takeaways on preserving relevant data

The rules mandate a reasonable attempt to preserve evidence; they don’t require perfection. The judge here shared an instructive message for all e-discovery counsel: “Given the relative cheapness of digital storage, parties will have less and less justification to permit key employees to utilize discretion in the retention of ESI. Certainly, the best approach is to implement a server-side hold on all digital data utilized by key employees and to later use search algorithms to parse relevance…. [B]usinesses that utilize email jail to conserve server space should shut down such features for employees subject to a litigation hold.”

[View source.]

Written by:

Zapproved LLC

Zapproved LLC on:

Readers' Choice 2017
Reporters on Deadline

"My best business intelligence, in one easy email…"

Your first step to building a free, personalized, morning email brief covering pertinent authors and topics on JD Supra:
Sign up using*

Already signed up? Log in here

*By using the service, you signify your acceptance of JD Supra's Privacy Policy.
Custom Email Digest
Privacy Policy (Updated: October 8, 2015):

JD Supra provides users with access to its legal industry publishing services (the "Service") through its website (the "Website") as well as through other sources. Our policies with regard to data collection and use of personal information of users of the Service, regardless of the manner in which users access the Service, and visitors to the Website are set forth in this statement ("Policy"). By using the Service, you signify your acceptance of this Policy.

Information Collection and Use by JD Supra

JD Supra collects users' names, companies, titles, e-mail address and industry. JD Supra also tracks the pages that users visit, logs IP addresses and aggregates non-personally identifiable user data and browser type. This data is gathered using cookies and other technologies.

The information and data collected is used to authenticate users and to send notifications relating to the Service, including email alerts to which users have subscribed; to manage the Service and Website, to improve the Service and to customize the user's experience. This information is also provided to the authors of the content to give them insight into their readership and help them to improve their content, so that it is most useful for our users.

JD Supra does not sell, rent or otherwise provide your details to third parties, other than to the authors of the content on JD Supra.

If you prefer not to enable cookies, you may change your browser settings to disable cookies; however, please note that rejecting cookies while visiting the Website may result in certain parts of the Website not operating correctly or as efficiently as if cookies were allowed.

Email Choice/Opt-out

Users who opt in to receive emails may choose to no longer receive e-mail updates and newsletters by selecting the "opt-out of future email" option in the email they receive from JD Supra or in their JD Supra account management screen.


JD Supra takes reasonable precautions to insure that user information is kept private. We restrict access to user information to those individuals who reasonably need access to perform their job functions, such as our third party email service, customer service personnel and technical staff. However, please note that no method of transmitting or storing data is completely secure and we cannot guarantee the security of user information. Unauthorized entry or use, hardware or software failure, and other factors may compromise the security of user information at any time.

If you have reason to believe that your interaction with us is no longer secure, you must immediately notify us of the problem by contacting us at In the unlikely event that we believe that the security of your user information in our possession or control may have been compromised, we may seek to notify you of that development and, if so, will endeavor to do so as promptly as practicable under the circumstances.

Sharing and Disclosure of Information JD Supra Collects

Except as otherwise described in this privacy statement, JD Supra will not disclose personal information to any third party unless we believe that disclosure is necessary to: (1) comply with applicable laws; (2) respond to governmental inquiries or requests; (3) comply with valid legal process; (4) protect the rights, privacy, safety or property of JD Supra, users of the Service, Website visitors or the public; (5) permit us to pursue available remedies or limit the damages that we may sustain; and (6) enforce our Terms & Conditions of Use.

In the event there is a change in the corporate structure of JD Supra such as, but not limited to, merger, consolidation, sale, liquidation or transfer of substantial assets, JD Supra may, in its sole discretion, transfer, sell or assign information collected on and through the Service to one or more affiliated or unaffiliated third parties.

Links to Other Websites

This Website and the Service may contain links to other websites. The operator of such other websites may collect information about you, including through cookies or other technologies. If you are using the Service through the Website and link to another site, you will leave the Website and this Policy will not apply to your use of and activity on those other sites. We encourage you to read the legal notices posted on those sites, including their privacy policies. We shall have no responsibility or liability for your visitation to, and the data collection and use practices of, such other sites. This Policy applies solely to the information collected in connection with your use of this Website and does not apply to any practices conducted offline or in connection with any other websites.

Changes in Our Privacy Policy

We reserve the right to change this Policy at any time. Please refer to the date at the top of this page to determine when this Policy was last revised. Any changes to our privacy policy will become effective upon posting of the revised policy on the Website. By continuing to use the Service or Website following such changes, you will be deemed to have agreed to such changes. If you do not agree with the terms of this Policy, as it may be amended from time to time, in whole or part, please do not continue using the Service or the Website.

Contacting JD Supra

If you have any questions about this privacy statement, the practices of this site, your dealings with this Web site, or if you would like to change any of the information you have provided to us, please contact us at:

- hide
*With LinkedIn, you don't need to create a separate login to manage your free JD Supra account, and we can make suggestions based on your needs and interests. We will not post anything on LinkedIn in your name. Or, sign up using your email address.