The Second Circuit Court of Appeals recently partially refused to enforce a foreign arbitration award on the ground that it was required to give comity to a foreign court decision concerning that award.

Esso Exploration and Production Nigeria Ltd. entered into a contractual agreement with the Nigerian government to develop Nigerian oil fields. The agreement provided that the Nigerian National Petroleum Corp. (NNPC) was entitled to obtain (“lift”) portions of the extracted oil. The agreement also included an arbitration clause requiring arbitration in Nigeria.

A dispute arose regarding whether NNPC was “lifting” more than it was allowed. Esso and NNPC arbitrated that issue in Nigeria and the arbitration panel awarded Esso approximately $1.8 billion plus interest. NNPC challenged that award in Nigerian courts. A Nigerian court set aside part of the award. Esso meanwhile petitioned the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York to confirm its arbitration award in full. The district court denied Esso’s petition in full, concluding that it was required to give comity to the Nigerian court decision.

The Second Circuit affirmed in part. It agreed that the district court was required to give comity to the Nigerian court’s decision but noted that the Nigerian court had only set aside the arbitration award in part. There was therefore nothing preventing U.S. courts from enforcing the aspect of the award that Nigerian courts had not vacated.

Esso Exploration & Production Nigeria Ltd. v. Nigerian National Petroleum Corp., No. 19-3159 (2d Cir. July 8, 2022)