The New York City Council has passed five bills as part of a legislative package intended to reform scheduling and workplace practices for fast food and retail workers in New York City.
The legislative package, first introduced on December 6, 2016, and passed on May 24, 2017 follows Mayor Bill de Blasio’s September 2016 announcement that his administration plans to implement greater protections for approximately 65,000 hourly fast food workers in the City. The bills now head to the Mayor’s desk for signature, which is expected shortly. The original package included six bills, but one (Int. 1399) regarding requests for modifications to worker schedules was not voted on by the Council.
Summaries of the passed bills are below, along with distinctions between the proposed and passed bills. Mayor de Blasio is expected to sign all of the bills.
All bills take effect 180 days after signing, and the bill on payroll deduction (Int. 1384) will sunset after two years. The newly created Office of Labor Standards within the New York City Department of Consumer Affairs (discussed below) has the power to implement the laws, promulgate rules, and conduct outreach prior to the effective date.
Intro 1387, sponsored by Council Member Corey Johnson (D-Manhattan), bans the practice of “on-call scheduling” for retail employees.
Under the bill, employers would be prohibited from scheduling a retail employee for any on-call hours (that is, requiring an employee to be available to work, to contact the employer, or to wait to be contacted by the employer) before determining whether the employee must report to work.
The bill also would prohibit employers from:
Scheduling a retail employee for any on-call shift;
Canceling a work shift with fewer than 72 hours’ notice;
Requiring a retail employee to work with fewer than 72 hours’ notice, unless the employee consents in writing; and
Requiring a retail employee to contact an employer to confirm whether the employee should report for his or her scheduled shift in the 72 hours before the start of the shift.
The final bill allows retail employers to make schedule changes or to cancel shifts within 72 hours of the start of the scheduled shift without penalty:
To give an employee time off or to allow a retail employee to voluntarily trade shifts with another retail employee; or
If the employer’s operations cannot begin or continue.
Consecutive Work Shifts
Intro 1388, also sponsored by Council Member Johnson, bans consecutive work shifts in fast food restaurants involving both the closing and opening of the restaurant.
The bill would prohibit employers from requiring fast food employees to work back-to-back shifts, when the first shift closes the restaurant and the second shift opens it the next day, with fewer than 11 hours in between (which the bill coins as “clopening” shifts), unless the employee requests to work such shifts or consents in writing. If an employer schedules such back-to-back shifts, it must pay the employee an additional $100.
Shifts to Current Employees
Intro 1395, sponsored by Council Member Brad Lander (D-Brooklyn), requires fast food employers to offer work shifts to current employees before hiring additional employees.
The bill states that whenever a fast food employer has additional regular or on-call work shifts to provide in any fast food job position, the employer must first offer such shifts to current employees at the specific location where the additional shifts are needed before the employer can hire any additional employees or subcontractors (including temporary staffing agencies) to fill the shifts.
When shifts become available, the employer must conspicuously post the number and nature of all shifts being offered and assign additional shifts to any employee who has responded to the offer of work. Employers would be required to offer all available hours until interested employees would be required to receive overtime pay, or until all current employees have rejected available hours, whichever comes first.
Fair Work Week
Intro 1396, also sponsored by Council Member Lander, would create general provisions for a new “fair work week” chapter in the City’s Administrative Code that outlines oversight by the Department of Consumer Affairs.
The bill also would require fast food employers to provide employees with an estimate of their work schedule upon hire and regular work schedules outlining all shifts with 14 days’ advanced notice for a period of at least 7 days, and include all regular and on-call shifts that the employee will be required to work or be available to work.
Moreover, it would require that an employer pay the following different premiums to the employee when making a scheduling change:
If additional shifts or hours are added to a shift, or if the date, start, or end times of a shift are changed with no loss of hours with notice to the employee of fewer than 14 days, but at least 7 days’ notice, the employer must pay an additional $10 for each schedule change.
If hours are subtracted or if a shift is cancelled with notice to the employee of fewer than 14 days, but at least 7 days, an employer must pay $20 for each schedule change.
If shifts or hours to a shift are added, or the date, start, or end time or a shift changes with no loss of hours with notice to the employee of less than 7 days, an employer must pay $15 for each schedule change.
If hours are subtracted from a shift or the shift is cancelled with less than 7 days’ notice, but at least 24 hours’ notice to the employee, the employer must pay $45 for each schedule change.
If hours are subtracted or if a shift is cancelled with fewer than 24 hours’ notice to the employee, the employer must pay $75 for each schedule change.
An employer is not required to provide premium pay when operations cannot begin or continue due to severe weather conditions that pose a threat to employee safety. However, if the employer adds shifts to an employee’s schedule to cover for or replace another employee who cannot safely travel to work, the covering employee is paid premium pay according to the schedule. Further, an employer is not required to provide premium pay when two employees voluntarily trade shifts.
Intro 1384, sponsored by Council Member Julissa Ferreras-Copeland (D-Queens), provides fast food workers with the ability to make voluntary contributions to not-for-profit organizations of their choice through payroll deductions. The purpose of this legislation is to make it easier for employees to support advocacy organizations working on their behalf.
The bill outlines standards for organizations eligible to receive the contributions. It also establishes a minimum contribution of $6 per biweekly paycheck and $3 per weekly paycheck in order to minimize the burden to the employer.
For purposes of this legislative package, the term “fast food establishment” means any establishment:
that has as its primary purpose serving food or drink items;
where patrons order or select items and pay before eating and such items may be consumed on the premises, taken out, or delivered to the customer’s location;
that offers limited service;
that is part of a chain; and
that is one of 30 or more establishments nationally, including (A) an integrated enterprise that owns or operates 30 or more such establishments in the aggregate nationally or (B) an establishment operated pursuant to a franchise where the franchisor and the franchisees of such franchisor own or operate 30 or more such establishments in the aggregate nationally.
The term “fast food employee” means any person employed or permitted to work at or for a fast food establishment by any employer that is located within the City where such job duties include at least one of the following:
cooking, food, or drink preparation,
stocking supplies or equipment,
Other Council Activity
New York City employers should note the recent enactment of an important employment law limiting a prospective employer’s ability to obtain and use salary history information from job applicants. (For further information, see our article, NYC Enacts New Law Limiting Prospective Employers’ Ability to Obtain and Use Salary History.) This law will go into effect on October 31, 2017.
New York City employers also should note that, effective May 15, 2017, the “Freelance Isn’t Free Act” delineates additional duties for businesses contracting with freelance workers on or after May 15, 2017, in New York City. (For further information, see our article, New NYC Law Imposes Additional Requirements on Companies Contracting With Freelancers.)
While not employment-based, other proposed legislation relevant to New York employers would increase the minimum threshold for application of the Commercial Rent Tax, which applies to certain businesses below 96th Street in Manhattan.