Navigating the intricate landscape of employment laws and regulations can be daunting, and Virginia’s termination laws are no exception. We often encounter clients with various misconceptions about the laws governing termination in Virginia. These misconceptions can lead to misunderstandings, disputes, and even legal complications.

9 Common Virginia Termination Law Misconceptions

In this article, we will shed light on the most common misconceptions about Virginia termination laws. Understanding these mistaken beliefs can help you make informed decisions and avoid legal pitfalls.

All Employees in Virginia are At-Will Employees

One of the most prevalent fallacies is the belief that all employees in Virginia are automatically employed at will, which means employers can terminate them at any time for any reason. While at-will employment is the default rule in Virginia, employers must recognize that exceptions exist.

For example, employment contracts, whether written or implied, can define the terms of the employment relationship. When an employer and employee enter into a written employment contract, it may supersede the default at-will relationship. If the contract addresses term and termination, then the contract will dictate how and under what circumstances termination can occur.

Employers and employees should know that employment contracts and collective bargaining agreements can limit an employer’s ability to terminate an employee without cause. Violating these agreements can result in claims of breach of contract and wrongful discharge.

Furthermore, Virginia recognizes public policy exceptions to the at-will doctrine, which means employers cannot terminate employees for reasons that violate public policy, such as refusing to engage in illegal activities or reporting workplace safety violations.

Employers Can Terminate Workers for Any Reason Without Consequences

Another common misconception is that employers in Virginia can terminate employees for any reason without the risk of facing an employment lawsuit. While Virginia’s at-will employment doctrine provides significant flexibility to employers, it does not grant them carte blanche to terminate employees without accountability.

Employers cannot terminate employees for discriminatory reasons based on protected characteristics such as race, color, sex (including pregnancy and childbirth), gender identity, age, religion, veteran status, disability, marital status, or genetic information. Additionally, terminating employees in retaliation for protected activities, such as whistleblowing or filing a discrimination complaint, is prohibited under federal and state employment laws. Employers who disregard these protections can find themselves facing costly legal actions.

Severance Pay is Guaranteed Upon Termination

Some employees believe they are entitled to severance pay upon termination, regardless of the circumstances. In Virginia, there is generally no legal requirement for employers to provide severance pay unless an employment contract or company policy specifies otherwise.

Severance packages are typically offered at an employer’s discretion, often as a goodwill gesture or as part of a negotiated settlement or exit agreement. While some employees may receive severance pay, it is not an automatic entitlement in Virginia, and the terms of severance packages can vary widely.

Employees Cannot Challenge Wrongful Termination in Virginia

Sometimes, employees think challenging a termination in Virginia is futile due to the state’s at-will employment doctrine. However, employees have legal recourse to challenge wrongful terminations, discrimination, retaliation, and violations of public policy. Employees can file complaints with government agencies such as the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) or the Virginia Division of Human Rights. They can also pursue legal action through civil lawsuits.

Employers Always Need Specific Reasons for Termination

Employers may believe they always need specific, well-documented reasons to terminate an employee. While it is true that employers should have legitimate, nondiscriminatory justifications for termination, they are not required to provide exhaustive documentation for every termination.

Employers must, however, avoid terminating employees for discriminatory, retaliatory, or unlawful reasons. Employers should conduct terminations following employment laws and regulations to mitigate the risk of legal challenges.

Severance Agreements are Non-negotiable

Employees may assume that the terms of a severance agreement offered by their employer are non-negotiable. However, this is not necessarily the case. Employees have the right to review and negotiate the terms of a severance agreement, including the amount of severance pay, the duration of benefits, and confidentiality clauses.

No Advance Notice of Termination is Required

Some individuals believe that employers in Virginia can terminate employees without any notice. While the at-will employment doctrine does not require advance notice, if an employment contract requires advance notice, employers may be bound to comply.

Employers Cannot Fire Employees on Medical Leave

Employees often believe that they are protected from termination while on medical leave. While employee protections against termination exist under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), these protections are not absolute, and employers can terminate employees under certain circumstances.

Employees Cannot be Fired for Poor Performance

A final misunderstanding is that employers are unable to terminate employees for poor performance. However, employers can indeed terminate employees for not meeting job expectations, so long as the reasons are not based on discriminatory factors.

Why Employers Should Discuss Employment Termination Matters with Counsel

Misconceptions about Virginia termination laws can create confusion, frustration, and legal challenges for both employers and employees. It is crucial to dispel these mistaken beliefs and gain a clear understanding of the complexities of Virginia’s employment laws to avoid wrongful discharge claims.

[View source.]