Delaware Chancery Court’s contractarian approach to all things LLC, embedded statutorily in Section 18-1101(b) of the Delaware LLC Act (“It is the policy of this chapter to give the maximum effect to the principle of freedom...more
Folks who’ve been following this blog for years know that periodically I like to venture beyond New York’s borders to find and report on interesting decisions from other states in business divorce cases....more
Last week, the Manhattan-based Appellate Division, First Department, handed down one of the more intriguing decisions by a New York court I’ve seen in a long time involving a dispute between LLC members....more
3/18/2024
/ Breach of Contract ,
Business Disputes ,
Business Divorce ,
Contract Terms ,
Entrepreneurs ,
Investment ,
Investors ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Merger Clause ,
Operating Agreements ,
Oral Contracts
In my business divorce practice I deal with many closely held corporations that have only a few or perhaps just two shareholders, each of whom is actively involved in running the business. Within that category are many...more
It’s a bit of a stretch to suggest that King Solomon prophesied the standard for judicial dissolution of LLCs, but there it is: under New York’s judicially construed standard for involuntary dissolution under Section 702 of...more
Those of us who follow the Delaware Chancery Court’s output are regularly treated to lengthy, detailed, finely crafted opinions sometimes in excess of 100 pages. Opinions of that length from our New York state court judges...more
7/18/2022
/ Bad Faith ,
Breach of Duty ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Capital Calls ,
Co-Ownership ,
Contract Disputes ,
Contract Terms ,
Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing ,
Financing ,
Joint Venture ,
Motion to Dismiss ,
Passive Investments
Are claims for judicial dissolution of business entities arbitrable? -
It’s a question I’m occasionally asked by business owners and, surprisingly, by lawyers. I say surprisingly because here in New York, the courts long...more
Appearances can be deceiving. -
That, essentially, was the argument made in two recently decided cases involving claims for judicial dissolution. ...more
11/15/2021
/ Breach of Duty ,
Business Disputes ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Contract Terms ,
Employment Contract ,
Fraudulent Conveyance ,
Judicial Dissolution ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Membership Interest ,
Operating Agreements ,
Purchase Price ,
Stock Transfer ,
Unjust Enrichment
Who says email is more efficient and cheaper than regular mail? -
Not the manager of the McGuire family real estate business after winning a lower court ruling only to see it reversed on appeal last month in a decision...more
9/20/2021
/ Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Capital Calls ,
Contract Disputes ,
Contract Terms ,
Email ,
Family Businesses ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Membership Interest ,
Notice Requirements ,
Operating Agreements
Welcome to this 11th annual edition of Summer Shorts! This year’s edition features brief commentary on half a dozen business divorce cases of interest from across the country. ...more
8/30/2021
/ Business Divorce ,
Buyouts ,
Contract Terms ,
Fair Value Standard ,
Family Businesses ,
Judicial Dissolution ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Limited Partnerships ,
Membership Interest ,
Operating Agreements ,
Shareholders
My partner Frank McRoberts recently posted about two New York cases, one involving an LLC and the other a close corporation, in which the courts resolved conflicts between, on the one hand, provision in the...more
As I wrote here, in 2016 the Manhattan-based Appellate Division, First Department decided Raharney Capital LLC v Capital Stack LLC, overruling its own precedent and joining appellate rulings by the other Departments holding...more
Now that I’ve got your attention, relax. At least for New York LLCs, a member can be expelled from an LLC only if expressly authorized by the operating agreement....more
Of late I’ve been ruminating on New York’s membership in the shrinking pool of states that don’t recognize oppression of an LLC minority member by the controlling members or managers as ground for judicial dissolution....more
4/19/2021
/ Books & Records ,
Breach of Duty ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Closely Held Businesses ,
Contract Terms ,
Dissolution ,
Fiduciary Duty ,
Judicial Dissolution ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Minority Shareholders ,
Operating Agreements ,
Shareholder Distributions ,
Shareholder Oppression
It’s not unusual to find buy-out provisions in shareholder and operating agreements that commit the pricing of the buy-out to the “final and binding” determination of one or more appraisers. The same agreements also may...more
2/15/2021
/ Appraisal ,
Arbitration Agreements ,
Arbitration Awards ,
Business Divorce ,
Buy-Out Agreements ,
Closely Held Businesses ,
Contract Terms ,
Fair Market Value ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Membership Interest ,
Operating Agreements ,
PricewaterhouseCoopers ,
Repurchase Agreements ,
Shareholders
The restaurant business is on the skids amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Yelp reports that 60% of closed restaurants won’t re-open.
Apart from the pandemic, the success rate for new restaurants is dauntingly low. Surveys show a...more
Don’t Miss the 2020 LLC Institute Virtual Meeting!
It’s that time of year again, when leading experts and practitioners in the field of closely held business entities gather for the LLC Institute’s spectacular CLE program....more
“The Company is formed for any valid business purpose”
Nine seemingly benign words in the garden-variety operating agreement of a realty holding LLC. Nine words that, as one judge opined under similar circumstances some...more
As regular readers of the blog surely are aware, there are few provisions in an LLC or shareholders agreement more likely to be the focus of dispute than the buy-sell provision. Most times, these disputes expose a flaw in the...more
Was it “an unfortunate attempt to second-guess or even force a ‘do over’ of the appraisal,” as the one side would have it? Or was it a “rigged” and “corrupted” appraisal process that took place behind closed doors and...more
Two of my pet topics — dysfunctional buy-sell agreements and application of federal court abstention doctrine in private company disputes — intersect in a decision issued last month in Ray v Raj Bedi Revocable Trust, Case No....more
The proverb “All for the want of a horseshoe nail” aptly describes the possibly mortal blow dealt by the Appellate Division’s recent decision in Favourite Ltd. v Cico, 2020 NY Slip Op 01463 [1st Dept Mar. 3, 2020], to a...more
The case of Shapiro v Ettenson ranks as one of the more consequential ones in the realm of New York’s LLC jurisprudence....more
2/4/2020
/ Arbitration ,
Bad Faith ,
Breach of Contract ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Capital Calls ,
Contract Disputes ,
Contract Terms ,
Damages ,
Expulsion ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Member Removal ,
Membership Interest ,
Operating Agreements
I’ve lost track of how many lawsuits I’ve seen between co-owners of New York City restaurants. It’s not surprising given the high percentage of restaurant failures in an intensely competitive market with high rents, high...more
12/2/2019
/ Books & Records ,
Business Assets ,
Business Litigation ,
Commercial Court ,
Contract Terms ,
Dismissals ,
Fraud Abuse and Waste ,
Intellectual Property Protection ,
IP License ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Operating Agreements ,
Partnerships ,
Professional Misconduct ,
Restaurant Industry ,
Theft ,
Trademarks
In 2018, two members of a realty holding LLC sought judicial dissolution based on the death of one of the other members. The operating agreement defines a member’s death as an event of “Dissociation.”...more
11/18/2019
/ Appeals ,
Business Divorce ,
Business Litigation ,
Contract Disputes ,
Contract Negotiations ,
Contract Terms ,
Decedent Protection ,
Dismissals ,
Dissolution ,
Inheritance ,
Judicial Dissolution ,
Limited Liability Company (LLC) ,
Membership Interest ,
Operating Agreements ,
Property Valuation ,
Real Estate Market ,
Rental Property