News & Analysis as of

Reinsurance Utica Mutual Insurance Co.

White and Williams LLP

Second Circuit Says Cedent Cannot Use the “Follow-the-Settlements” Doctrine to Circumvent Plain, Unambiguous Policy Provision

White and Williams LLP on

In Utica Mutual Insurance Company v. Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, reversing a jury verdict in the District Court, held that the “follow-the-settlements” doctrine does not...more

Carlton Fields

NDNY Unable to Resolve Ambiguity in Umbrella Policies and Sets Trial

Carlton Fields on

On remand from the Second Circuit, the Northern District of New York was asked to determine whether Utica Mutual Insurance Co. (the cedent) had a defense obligation under its umbrella policies. If it did, then Utica would be...more

Carlton Fields

Northern District Of New York Declines To Imply A Follow-The-Fortunes Or Follow-The-Settlements Obligation In Reinsurance...

Carlton Fields on

After a ten-day bench trial involving ten fact witnesses and five expert witnesses, the Northern District of New York found that certain facultative certificates did not implicitly contain follow-the-settlements or...more

Carlton Fields

Court Declines To Reconsider Summary Judgment Decision In Latest Development In Ongoing Asbestos Liability Reinsurance Litigation

Carlton Fields on

The Northern District of New York declined to reconsider a September 2018 decision on competing motions for partial summary judgment we previously reported on in a long-running reinsurance dispute related to asbestos...more

Carlton Fields

Years-Long Asbestos Reinsurance Battle Continues For Utica And Century, Including Whether Century Must Follow The Fortunes Of...

Carlton Fields on

In 2013, Utica Mutual Insurance Company (the cedent) filed a complaint alleging that Century Indemnity Company (the reinsurer) (1) breached two reinsurance certificates executed between the parties covering the years 1973 and...more

Carlton Fields

Second Circuit Partially Vacates Summary Judgment Ruling In Asbestos Risk Reinsurance Case

Carlton Fields on

The Second Circuit has partially vacated summary judgment rulings in a case involving the reinsurance of asbestos-related risks. ...more

Carlton Fields

Northern District Of New York Allows Evidence That Follow The Fortunes Or Follow The Settlements Provision Could Be Implied In...

Carlton Fields on

Munich Reinsurance America, Inc. and Utica Mutual Insurance are headed to a bench trial in the United States District Court for the Northern District of New York in a case regarding two facultative reinsurance certificates...more

Carlton Fields

New York Federal Court Largely Denies Motions for Summary Judgment on Issues in Breach of Facultative Reinsurance Certificate...

Carlton Fields on

Defendant, Munich Re, moved for summary judgment relating to defense costs and allocation and Plaintiff, Utica, moved for summary judgment as to Munich Re’s claim for reimbursement. The Court denied the motions with the...more

Carlton Fields

Federal Court Denies Reinsurer’s Post-Trial Motions In Long-Running Dispute Which Resulted In A Verdict In Its Cedent’s Favor

Carlton Fields on

A federal district court has denied both a motion for judgment as a matter of law or for a new trial and a motion to correct the interest calculation filed by Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company after a jury award of $35 million...more

Carlton Fields

NDNY Jury Awards $35m Plus Interest For Amounts Due Under Reinsurance Contracts

Carlton Fields on

Following a jury trial, Utica Mutual Insurance Company was awarded $35 million, plus interest ($29,092,191.78) on its claims against Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company to enforce the terms of the certificates of reinsurance...more

Carlton Fields

Less Than Two Weeks Before Trial, District Court Judge In Utica V. Fireman’s Fund Rules On Motions In Limine

Carlton Fields on

This case concerns an action filed by Utica Mutual Insurance Company (Utica) against its reinsurer, Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company (FFIC) seeking to enforce certain reinsurance contracts against FFIC with respect to...more

Carlton Fields

Court Rejects Motion To Seal Summary Judgment Exhibits When Moving Party Fails To Provide Sufficient Factual Justification For...

Carlton Fields on

Utica Mutual Insurance Company’s request that numerous exhibits filed in support of summary judgment be sealed has been rejected by a federal district court, which found that Utica’s general statements about the documents...more

Carlton Fields

New York Federal Court Denies Cross Motions For Summary Judgment On Follow The Settlements Doctrine

Carlton Fields on

In a lengthy February 24, 2017 opinion, a New York federal court denied cross motions for summary judgment on the Follow the Settlements Doctrine, filed by Utica Mutual Insurance Company and Utica’s reinsurer, Fireman’s Fund...more

Carlton Fields

Court Upholds Attorney-Client Privilege In Reinsurance Dispute, Rejecting Assertion Of The Crime-Fraud Exception And Questions...

Carlton Fields on

The case involves a dispute over Utica Mutual Insurance Company’s claims for reinsurance proceeds from Munich Re. One of Munich Re’s defenses in the litigation asserts that Utica “strategically orchestrated a settlement...more

Carlton Fields

New York Trial Court Finds Cedent Is Not Covered For Loss Adjustment And Legal Expenses In Excess Of The Amounts Stated In Its...

Carlton Fields on

Relying on past New York precedent, a New York state trial court determined the language of certain reinsurance certificates at issue were unambiguous, declining to accept plaintiff’s extraneous evidence “that the custom and...more

Carlton Fields

Court Limits Discovery Of Insurer’s Policies With Other Insureds, Compels Production Of Prior Arbitration Testimony

Carlton Fields on

Utica Mutual Insurance Company (“Utica”) sued R&Q Reinsurance Company (“R&Q) in New York federal court for payment under reinsurance certificates R&Q issued to Utica covering umbrella policies Utica issued to its insured,...more

Carlton Fields

Is There Rhyme Or Reason To The Scope Of Permissible Reinsurance-Related Discovery?

Carlton Fields on

Courts in numerous jurisdictions continue to consider whether reinsurance-related information is discoverable in insurance coverage litigation. Decisions go both ways. Some courts find that reinsurance information and...more

Carlton Fields

Motion For Reconsideration Of Partial Summary Judgment Denied Concerning Liability Cap On Reinsurance Certificates

Carlton Fields on

A district court in New York denied an insurer’s motion for reconsideration of a partial summary judgment order in favor of the reinsurer that concluded that the reinsurance limits set forth nine certificates of reinsurance...more

Carlton Fields

Voluntary-Involuntary Rule Implicated In Removal Proceeding

Carlton Fields on

In late April, a district court in New York granted plaintiff Utica Mutual Insurance Company’s (“Utica”) motion to remand, implicating the voluntary-involuntary removal rule. Utica originally filed a breach of contract...more

Carlton Fields

Utica And Century Ordered To Mandatory Mediation In Reinsurance Dispute

Carlton Fields on

Utica Mutual Insurance Company brought an action in 2013 against Century Indemnity Company (itself and against certain of its named predecessors) for breach of contract and breach of the duty of utmost good faith, as well as...more

Saul Ewing LLP

Reinsurance Redux - January 2013

Saul Ewing LLP on

In This Issue: Federal Court in Wisconsin Holds That It Lacks Jurisdiction to Address Disqualification of Counsel in Arbitration The United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin declined to...more

21 Results
 / 
View per page
Page: of 1

"My best business intelligence, in one easy email…"

Your first step to building a free, personalized, morning email brief covering pertinent authors and topics on JD Supra:
*By using the service, you signify your acceptance of JD Supra's Privacy Policy.
- hide
- hide